| Schnapper's Hots | 122 | |
| Sweet Melissa's | 122 | |
| The Mad Hatter Restaurant | 120 | |
| Over Easy Café | 125 | |
| Beachview Steakhouse & Seafood Restaurant | 125 | |
| Sanibel Café | 122 | |
| Gramma Dot's | 119 | |
| The Island Cow | 117 | |
| Pinocchio's Original Italian Ice Cream | 117 | |
| Sanibel Steakhouse | 116 | |
| Twilight Cafe | 114 | |
| Sunset Grill | 113 | |
| Courtney's on Sanibel | 112 | |
| Jacaranda Restaurant | 111 | |
| Dolce Vita | 106 | |
| Blue Giraffe | 123 | |
| Il Tesoro | 120 | |
| Cheeburger Cheeburger | 119 | |
| Traders | 119 | |
| Ellington's Jazz Bar & Restaurant | 118 | |
| Hungry Heron | 117 | |
| Greenhouse Grill | 116 | |
| Mc T's Shrimp House | 115 | |
| Subway | 107 | |
| Huxters Market & Deli | 104 | |
